Genocide: The Global Human Rights Challenge
“Never Again?”
'In
50 years ago, following the genocidal murder of 6 million Jews (1.5 million children), the world joined Holocaust survivors in chanting this mantra: “Never Again…. Never again will we be hunted down and killed. Never again will we live in fear. Never again, never again.” [i] Since that time, the world community made a solemn promise to be vigilant and to prevent genocide from rearing its ugly head on the planet again.
Families that have had to bear the historical, emotional and psychological scars of genocide such as the Drissman family, provide this profound reminder to the world: “Never again is a wonderful mantra. It ranks right up there with ‘we won’t negotiate with terrorists.” Of course we know that words mean nothing. Only action counts.”[ii]
Several conventions have passed resolutions and ratifications to prevent and punish war crimes and genocidal killings. Two such documents include: The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. This article was approved and proposed for signature and ratification or accession by the United Nations General Assembly resolution 260 A (III) of 9 December 1948 . It saw it’s entry into force 12 January 1951 , in accordance with article XIII. The other is The Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes and Crimes against Humanity. It was adopted and opened for signature, ratification and accession by the UN General Assembly resolution 2391 (XXIII) of 26 November 1968 and later entered into force 11 November 1970, in accordance with article VIII.[iii]
The world’s dismal record of preventing genocide is proof enough of the failure to enforce the substance of these and other resolutions. Virtually every single continent on the planet has witnessed genocide, ethnic cleansing, or large scale political murders since the Holocaust.
In
The Early Explorers
Historians are quick to remind us that Genocide has been a ‘recurring nightmare’ for centuries. Ward Churchill, professor of Native American studies at the
"For his second voyage to the
For its sheer scale, duration and brutality, the North American institution of Slavery and the antecedent Atlantic Slave trade, ranks very high on the all time list of man’s inhumane treatment of his fellow man.
“The Atlantic Slave Trade linked four continents in a tragic uprooting and subjugation of millions of Africans, the largest ‘forced migration’ in the history of the world that lasted more than four hundred years between the fifteenth and the nineteenth centuries.”[vi]
According to P.D. Curtin, distinguished Professor of History at
Other early explorers, merchants and discovers were equally vicious, as the harrowing account of the plight of the Aboriginals on the Australian continent indicates. Beginning with the first foreign settlements in 1788, the population of the native inhabitants of that country declined through several means of ‘systematic annihilation’ from a high of 750,000 in the late 18th century to just 31,000 a century later. Most aboriginals succumbed to new diseases introduced by the settlers. Documents indicate that about 20,000 were murdered![viii]
B.A. Robinson of Ontario Consultants on Religious Tolerance elucidates:
In those days, "The Sydney Herald claimed that blacks had bestowed no labor upon the land - their ownership, their right, was nothing more than that of the Emu or the Kangaroo. Courts rejected Aboriginal evidence, because non-Christians could not swear oaths, and the killers used 'the defense that Aboriginal morality did not exist.” [ix]
The aggression against Aboriginals persisted for more than 60 years into the 20th century in the form of government sanctioned assimilation policies that uprooted and then placed upwards of 30% of Aboriginal children in the care of white families. The goal of the government was to assimilate “these people into the general population.” A historical milestone that ‘added insult to injury’ came in the form of a government law that granted Aboriginals, original natives of the continent, citizenship of Australia in 1967.”[x]
Imperialism and World Conflicts
Expanding empires and world wars have long provided the milieu for human rights violations. The British (India - Jallianwallah Bagh massacre, etc), Belgian (Congo), French (Algeria), Spanish (conquistadors in the Americas), and Portuguese (Mozambique - Mueda’s massacre) are all guilty of human rights abuses and atrocities perpetrated against native populations that they conquered, colonized and subjugated through out the world. However, nothing that occurred in these empires is as glaring an example of outright genocide as what occurred during the second year of the First World War, in the
Not to be outdone, on
World War II saw the resurgence of unspeakable war offenses. Armed with racial and religious bigotry, disseminated by a highly organized ideological and political propaganda apparatus, the Nazis succeeded in keeping the majority German population in a state of “mental and physical paralysis” from 1940-45. During this time, they wiped out a third of the world’s Jewish population, 3 million Poles (10% of the population), as well as one third of the Catholic priests in
Borrowing a leaf from the Nazis, a segment of the minority population settled in
Dictators, ideological and religious extremists
Stalin
Joseph Stalin, ruled the U.S.S.R. from 1929 to 1953 and into the early phase of the Cold War. His tyrannical, “iron fisted” dictatorship resulted in the death, disappearance and execution of upwards of 41[xiv]million soviet citizens. Between 1936 and 1939, during a period known as the Great Purge, “1.2 million Communist party members -- more than half the party -- were arrested, of which 600,000 died by torture, execution or perished in the Gulag.”[xv] His tactics are clearly highlighted in this passage from the United Human Rights Council:
“Joseph Stalin set in motion events designed to cause a famine in the
The second half of the 20th Century
The latter half of the 20th century witnessed several cases of genocide rivaling the Holocaust. In
Religious, racial or political exterminations occurred in
The African Tragedies
Some scholars believe that
“When I came out, there were no birds,” said one survivor who had hidden throughout the genocide. “There was sunshine and the stench of death.”[xviii]
A decade ago, ‘as the world slept,’ an estimated 800,000 Rwandans were killed in a horrifyingly short span of 100 days. Early, simplistic analysis of the tragedy blamed the genocide on ancient animosities between the Tutsis and Hutus. In his landmark book published in 1998, called "We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families: Stories from
“Gourevitch debunks the notion that the genocide was the inevitable result of "ancient" tribal enmities. The hatred was of a more recent vintage. For centuries Tutsis and Hutus were porous constructs - based on class as well as racial distinctions - until
Garrow goes further:
“Gourevitch issues a damning indictment of the United Nations, whose top bureaucrats received unequivocal evidence of an imminent Holocaust, but cut and ran after 10 Belgian peacekeepers were murdered and mutilated the first night of the massacres. The
Today, this south-central African nation is still struggling to come to terms with and to heal the psychological, emotional, social, economic and political wounds left behind by the genocide and its subsequent humanitarian upheaval.
Sadly, a decade after the horror of
Religious intolerance: The bane of the 21st century
“O People,” the prophet had said, “just as you regard as sacred this month and this day [the day of Hajj] and this city [
The colossal African American Intellectual W.E.B. Dubois defined the 20th century’s greatest challenge as the “... the problem of the colour line; of the relations between the lighter and darker races of man ...” At the turn of the 21st century, all indications point to religious intolerance and its corollaries as the greatest obstacle to world peace and stability! Conflicts in the Middle East, Cyprus, Chechnya, India/Pakistan, Indonesia, Nigeria, the Philippines, Mauritania, Macedonia, Germany’s neo-Nazism, the Basque region of France, and simmering undercurrent resentments in post war Balkans; all have the underpinnings of religious intolerance.
Perhaps no where on earth is this more glaring than in
Today we are again silent spectators to a horrifying drama in the
A civil war has raged in Sudan for over 18 months, involving Black African farmers and the Arab militia – both predominantly Muslim. The farmers, represented by two groups, the Sudan Liberation Movement and the Justice and Equality Movement have been overwhelmed by the Sudanese government backed armed militias called the Janjaweed, who have with vicious impunity, terrorized, murdered and raped black African rebels in Darfur – a region that lies to the west of this, the largest country in Africa. The governments tactics have been typical- Sudanese military planes have bombed villages, after which Arab militias have been brought in, often on horses, to rape and kill survivors.
The humanitarian Crisis in
A Mother in a Refugee Camp
No Madonna and Child could touch
Her tenderness for a son
She soon would have to forget. . . .
The air was heavy with odors of diarrhea,
Of unwashed children with washed-out ribs
And dried-up bottoms waddling in labored steps
Behind blown-empty bellies. Other mothers there
Had long ceased to care, but not this one:
She held a ghost-smile between her teeth,
And in her eyes the memory
Of a mother's pride. . . . She had bathed him
And rubbed him down with bare palms.
She took from their bundle of possessions
A broken comb and combed
The rust-colored hair left on his skull
And then-humming in her eyes-began carefully to part it.
In their former life this was perhaps
A little daily act of no consequence
Before his breakfast and school; now she did it
Like putting flowers on a tiny grave.
---- By Chinua Achebe Collected Poems, Anchor Books, August 2004[xxi]
The United States Secretary of State Colin Powell testified recently before the Senate’s Foreign Relations Committee, calling the disaster in
Echoing Powell’s remarks have been sentiments by Mukesh Kapila, the U.N. humanitarian coordinator in
At the last count, over 50,000 villagers had died, over 1.5 million refugees were homeless and scores of thousands more lived in great dread of imminent attack and murder. According to several international aid agencies, close to 500,000 more men, women and children are at risk of perishing from the ravages of disease and hunger in the months ahead if immediate steps are not taken by the world community to end the
A recent Editorial published in The St Petersburg Times succinctly captures this sense of urgency: “The relief group Save the Children estimates that of the 1.2-million in so-called safe camps, at least 500,000 are under the age of 5. Children are the most vulnerable victims in a war, and meeting their needs is entirely dependent on a massive influx of peacekeepers and aid. Time is the enemy of this relief effort,” Save the Children's Charles MacCormack said recently. The world should heed his urgent appeal.”[xxiii]
The missing pieces of the puzzle
The present humanitarian disaster in
Since 1983, in a conflict involving north and south
The BBC illuminates: “The Arab killers and rapists in
The Sudanese government sanctions genocide in
Hassan Turabi, the leader of a major rebel group - the Justice and Equality Movement, and a powerful Muslim cleric, has been a scathing critic of the
John Penergast, an Africa expert at the International Crisis Group in Washington provides this additional perspective: He believes that the Sudanese government continues genocidal activities in Darfur because there's a risk that north- south peace talks could very well fail and that Darfur groups could then conceivably build alliances with southern and eastern rebels and generate “a solid military threat to Khartoum from five or six directions”.[xxvi]
The role of
Driven by its insatiable need for oil to fuel its rapidly expanding economy,
Over the past decade,
Human Rights Watch concluded that “while
It is little wonder; therefore, given her deep economic interests in
“The U.N. Security Council has been hamstrung by the pro-Khartoum policies of
Genocide -What Can Be Done?
Identify, confront and eliminate the roots of Genocide: Numerous studies indicate that war, ignorance, religious intolerance, hatred, racism, tyranny, and ‘orchestrated dehumanizing public discourse that denies whole groups of people their dignity and their rights’[xxxi] (The Nazis, Milosevic, Rwanda) lie at the foundation of factors that create the milieu for genocide to surface. Identifying these root causes is the simple step. Actually putting meaningful measures in place to confront these pathologies at their early stage and thus eliminating them is the challenge. Here are some suggestions:
Prevent armed conflict, protect civilians
Genocide almost always occurs during war.
A role for regional bodies such as the African
The world’s and the African Union’s anemic response to the worst humanitarian crisis on the planet is embarrassing and unconscionable. It is the hope that the current Chairman of the AU President Obasanjo, will call for an international coalition of forces including the AU, peace keepers from the United Nations, NATO and other bodies to halt the murderous madness and stop what international observers have described as a world lackadaisically witnessing an evil purge “in slow motion without intervening.”[xxxiii]
Strengthen Early Warning Systems and Structures:
Funding and strengthening the work of human rights watch dog organizations (Human Rights Watch); other human rights anti genocide groups (United Human Rights Council, Amnesty International etc) will be particularly novel in alerting the world about human rights abuses early for swift action against impending genocidal activity. To this end, a world depository of data about abuses of human rights abuses akin to the structure employed by Interpol (the international police outfit) is crucial in this fight against tyranny.
Confront and temper religious fundamentalism, hatred, racism and Intolerance
Fundamentalism has taken root and grown in many of the world's major religions, such as Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Buddhism, Sikhism, Hinduism, and Confucianism so points out Karen Armstrong in her book “The Battle for God.” This explosion in numbers she believes has been fueled by technological changes and modernity, and the pervasive nature of western liberal values and popular culture that fundamentalists find threatening.
Several other experts believe that fundamentalism can be tempered by promoting and exercising democratic freedoms, accomplishing the full emancipation of women, and celebrating pluralism. Other strategies would include encouraging ideological and cultural diversity, promoting openness and the acceptance of differences as well as enhancing social and economic well-being. This multi-pronged approach should start in the homes, schools and religious centers. Similar strategies could also be used to reduce other forms of hatred, racism and intolerance.[xxxiv]
Spread Democracy and improve educational systems
The 3rd president of the
Democratic societies that have the most educated populations also have the least repression of their citizenry. Freedom, by its very nature protects organized societies from tyrannical leadership. To maintain democratic principles across the globe, however, the educational systems of countries must be improved. The target for foreign aid for wealthy nations of 0.7% GNP that the UN set about two decades ago is not only attainable, but more than ever, imperative. These ‘monies’ should be utilized among other things, to shore up the educational sectors of at risk countries. Land mark research now points to the fact that one of the most salient avenues for lifting entire populations out of poverty and ignorance, is to improve the quality and amount of education of women.[xxxvi] Herein, perhaps, lays a novel strategy for combating the underpinnings of genocide.
Strengthen the International Court of Justice at
International Law regards Genocide as a crime against humanity. A treaty setting up a permanent International Criminal Court was signed and ratified by several countries in July 2002. However, a number of important nations such as
“We have little hope of preventing genocide, or reassuring those who live in fear of its recurrence, if people who have committed this most heinous of crimes are left at large, and not held accountable for their offenses. It is the hope that the world’s sole super power the
Chidi Chike Achebe is the Medical Director of
Contact: Bobofine6@hotmail.com
[ii] Ibid
[iii]Information from © Office of the High Commissioner
for Human Rights
[iv] Genocides, Politicides, and Other Mass Murder Since 1945, With Stages in 2004, ©2004 Gregory H. Stanton, Genocide Watch
[v] http://www.religioustolerance.org/genocide2.htmAlso "#671 - Columbus Day, 1999," at: http://www.rachel.org/bulletin/bulletin.cfm?Issue_ID=1591
[vii]Alderman, Clifford L., "Rum, Slaves, and Molasses: The Story of
Curtin, Phillip D., "The Atlantic Slave Trade: A Census",
Dow, George Francis, "Slave Ships and Slaving",
Howard, Thomas, "Black Voyage", Little, Brown, and Company,
Hoyt, Edwin P., "African Slavery", Abelard-Schuman Limited Company,
Kay, F. George, "The Shameful Trade", Frederick Muller Ltd.,
Klein, Herbert S., "The Middle Passage: Comparative Studies in the Atlantic Slave Trade",
Meltzer, Milton, "Slavery: From the Renaissance to Today", Cowles Book Company Inc.,
Plimmer, Charlotte and Denis, "Slavery: The Anglo-American Involvement", Harper and Row Publishers Inc.,
Rawley, James A., "The Transatlantic Slave Trade", W. W. Norton and Company,
Thomas, Hugh, "The Slave Trade: The History of the Atlantic Slave Trade: 1440-1870", Simon and Schuster Inc.,
[ix] B.A. Robinson. Copyright © 2001 to 2004 incl.
[x] Ibid.
[xi] Information from the Fact Sheet: Armenian Genocide. Knights of Vartan Armenian Research Center . The University of Michigan- Dearborn , Dearborn , MI .
Also "The Armenian Genocide," at: http://www.hr-action.org/armenia/
[xii] B.A. Robinson. Copyright © 2001 to 2004 incl.
Also:"
[xiii] B.A. Robinson. Copyright © 2001 to 2004 incl.
Also: Y.F. Edeiken, "Non-Jewish survivors and victims," The Holocaust History Project, at: http://www.holocaust-history.org/questions/
Richard C. Lucas, "Forgotten Holocaust: How could 5,000,000 be killed and forgotten?," at: http://www.holocaustforgotten.com/
"Excerpts from Vera Laska," at: http://www.mtsu.edu/~baustin/laska.html
"Genocide history brief," at: http://www.maxpages.com/genocide/Genocide_History
Eugen Kogon, "The Theory and Practice of Hell," Ferrar,
Frank Rector, "The Nazi Extermination of Homosexuals," Stein and Day,
"Jehovah's Witnesses and Nazi Germany Index," at: http://jehovah.to/general/nazi/
[xiv] Historians disagree over the total number of Soviet citizens that died under Stalin. This is a moderate number cited in the literature.
[xvii] The Yale University Cambodian Genocide Program http://www.yale.edu/cgp/index.html
[xix] Review of the book “We wish to inform you that tomorrow we will be killed with our families: Stories from
http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/books/1998/9811.hammer.darkness.html
[xx] Ibid.
[xxi] Chinua Achebe Collected Poems, Anchor Books,
[xxii] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/3549325.stm
[xxiii] http://www.sptimes.com/2004/09/21/Opinion/Time_is_the_enemy_in_.shtml
[xxiv] Christian Solidarity International Backgrounder:
[xxv] Various reports by Abraham McLaughlin of the Christian Science Monitor www.csmonitor.com Copyright © 2004
[xxvi] Ibid.
[xxvii] Human Rights Watch, “
Ibid. p. 20.
The government of
[xxviii] Ibid.
[xxix] Ibid.
[xxx] James Phillips “Pressure
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Africa/em943.cfm
[xxxi] UN Secretary General website: (www...un.org/ossg/sg/ ) For this press release, see Press Release SG/SM/9245
International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda (link to special UN website in 6 languages)
Resolution designating April 7, 2004 an International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda: On
Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide Adopted by Resolution 260 (III) A of the U.N. General Assembly on
Create a United Nations Genocide Prevention Focal Point and Genocide Prevention Center By Prof. Gregory Stanton, Ph.D., President, Genocide Watch
"Revised and updated report on the question of the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide" (July 2, 1985) "The Whitaker Report" prepared by Special Rapporteur Benjamin Whitaker and presented on
[xxxii] Ibid.
[xxxiii] Independent research
[xxxiv] http://waf.gn.apc.org/
[xxxv] http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/jefferson/quotations/jeff0600.htm
[xxxvi]Also see Fact Sheet, Office of the Senior Coordinator for International Women's Issues,
Also UN Secretary General website: (www...un.org/ossg/sg/ ) For this press release, see Press Release SG/SM/9245
International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda (link to special UN website in 6 languages)
Resolution designating April 7, 2004 an International Day of Reflection on the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda: On
Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide Adopted by Resolution 260 (III) A of the U.N. General Assembly on
Create a United Nations Genocide Prevention Focal Point and Genocide Prevention Center By Prof. Gregory Stanton, Ph.D., President, Genocide Watch
"Revised and updated report on the question of the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide" (July 2, 1985) "The Whitaker Report" prepared by Special Rapporteur Benjamin Whitaker and presented on
[xxxvii] Ibid.
<< Home